Facebook Commenting Widget & What It (could) means for FB Ads

20 02 2009
   

FB Comment Box

 

 

FB Comment Box

A little off topic here for this blog, but try to stay with me and my out-there theories…

So today, facebook launched a publicly available Commenting Widget for any site via its Facebook Connect program. This is a very powerful tool – as it gives the ability to any site/blog to allow their users to use facebook logins to post comments on the site. That means the site doesn’t have to convince the user to sign up for an account, fork over personal info, check there email and verify it etc etc. In this day and age everyone has a facebook account – and now if you have any desire at all to leave a comment on a site that users FB connect commenting widget, there is no sign up – you just login with your facebook credentials and boom  - you are verified and ready to leave a comment.

Now, you are probably asking – what the heck does this have to do with facebook ads (given the name of the blog – Ads on Facebook)? Well, here is what im thinking. If facebook can gain mass adoption across the web with this type of widget (which i think they will, given the points above) – they are in essence growing there “available impressions”. The elements inside the FB commenting widget are 100% controlled by facebook. While yes, you can change the background color and the such – you cant add any custom code or HTML to the widget (as most widgets work). So now Facebook has this block of code on your page that totally controls a (commenting) section of the page and can add anything they want. OK, so you know where im going with this – yes, they can use these widgets to display ads. 

Now, i understand that fb wouldn’t even dream of adding ads anytime soon – as they want as few obsicales as possible in front site owners so they implement the fb commenting widget. But lets look a few years down the line & half of the web is using facebook connect as a commenting widget – the same time fb is trying to pump revenue to prepare for and IPO… would it be so crazy for them to start placing their ads inside the widget??? Look at google, 6 months ago they didnt have ads showing half the products that they do now (maps, images, there are more – just cant think of any off the top of head) – and now, they are popping up everywhere google can put them. This is also how they started with search – ad-free until people “needed them” for search. Whats gonna happen when site owners need FB for their commenting system.

Or maybe, that havard drop out is even smarter than that & can use the commenting widget (and the other 100+ widgets im sure they are already developing) to create the adsense 2.0 fb-style. Its pretty easy once you got a million sites using your widgets – you give the site owner the option to add facebook ads to the widget and share the revenue via a facebook affiliate program.  And just like that, you double, triple your ad inventory… Couple that with the data that facebook can collect on your site – ie. the people who comment – what they like, what they do on fb etc etc. Damn talk about targeted ads!

Its amazing, that in this day and age – where it seems like the entire global economy is collapsing & the govt is about to take over the banking industry (if that doesn’t scare you nothing will!) — facebook keeps on better positioning itself to become the next big thing on the internet (oh, it already is…..)

Here is a 5 minute video facebook put out that shows you how to add the facebook commenting widget to your site in 5 minutes.

Let me know what you think in the comments. Am i crazy? Am i dead on? Do you have some other ideas how they can use these “widgets” for future business purposes?





Facebook Ads Minimum CPCs

12 02 2009

So a few days i ago i searched through the FB ads help center for any clues how they use CPCs (what is the minimum cpc? is the cpc only dependant on the max cpc & ad CTR (click-through-rate) – or is there a host of other stuff? is there a max cpc? can i enter a $100 cpc? etc etc etc)

Anyhow, i will document my findings in more detailed fashion with separate posts – but something just popped up in my facebook ads account that made me think of this specific item:

Facebook Min CPC

What was it? This:

 

Facebook Ad CPC Too Low

Facebook Ad CPC Too Low

So i see this message : 

Your bid on this ad may be too low. In order to get more impressions, we recommend that you increase your bid to at least $0.18. For more information about how bids work, please see our help page. Note that your ad is not paused and it is possible that you will continue to receive some impressions.

Now im thinking what, am i losing my mind? i know i read the minimum cpc is $0.01 – and i tried to set my ad to a 0.15 bid — but Facebook Ads is telling me no the minimum cpc for this ad is  $0.18. Now im guessing this has to do more with the history of the ad than any “system wide min cpcs”. But just as google loves to tell you the min cpc is 0.01, but you find me some terms that i can get an impression when my max cpc is at $0.01 (forget about a click…). Now i am almost sure that if i delete the ad (instead of lowering the cpc) and re-add it exactly the same – with a CPC of 0.15 it would have gone through and got impressions/clicks.

btw, since i was only lowering my bid to $0.15 & they only suggested a bid of $0.18  ”in order to get more impressions” & bec the ad was making money even at the old higher CPC i raised the CPC back up to $0.18. Although, i will be testing this in detail with other ads at which time i wont comply with their “suggestion” and see what happens. Ill report my findings here. 

This will be an interesting trend to track, if anyone gets this message when lowering a CPC or (gasp.) when starting a new ad – pls let me know in the comments.





Facebook Ads Offensive? Irrelevant?

12 02 2009

So the excitement of the day around facebook ads, is how a respected blogger and social media expert Louis Gray posted: I Just Marked All Facebook Ads as Offensive. So Should You. While i feel Louis’s pain, and if i had a nickel for every time i saw an offensive ad on the internet (been working here for over 10 yrs) i would be playing golf somewhere very warm.

Everyone just has to be a little patient … Like i said in a comment on Louis’s post:

Louis – you got to give them time….. Most people dont remember late 2000 when adwords launched it was also common to see non-relevant ads (and they didnt have to decode user profiles, they just had to match keywords).

In time the advertisers will come, fb will enhance their ad platform & using facebook ads will become as common as advertising on adwords.

im following the progress at my new blog; adsonfacebook.wordpress.com – check it out.

thanks

People are very quick to forget that facebook provides them with a FREE  social networking experience. No one is asking you to pay for using facebook, in fact they are telling you to use it as much as your heart desires & enjoy it – but lets try to cut them some slack as they prepare to try to build the most advanced advertising platform on the net ALL TO SUPPORT YOUR FREE & UNLIMITED USE OF FACEBOOK and all its features…

So, just ignore the ads for a while if they bother you & before you know it you will be asking how they heck the ads on facebook dont even feel like ads bec they soo damm relevent.

ok, </rant>





Must read blog posts on Facebook Ads.

11 02 2009

If you are new to facebook ads  (hey, thats all of us :) here are the two  three four MUST READ posts that i have come across. If you have any other suggestions, let me know in the comment and ill check it out. 

Wow, cant believe i forgot to post this one:

This is a must listen for ANYONE interested in facebook ads, this guy has been in charge of the facebook ad program for over a year – so grab a drink and listen to the interview here: http://www.webmasterradio.fm/Advertising/Shoemoney-Show/Facebook-Ads.htm

 

If video is more your speed, check out this ~10 min on a walk-though of setting up a new facebook ad and the options available. (note; i have watched tons on youtube fb ad walkthroughs & most of them are garbage – the one embedded below is actually quite informative for someone who never set up a facebook ad before.





Adding New Facebooks Ads – Got a few days?

11 02 2009

First off, i am not talking about the editorial review – from my experiences they approve the ad within at least 8 hours but as quickly as 2 or 3 (in my experiences anyway…).  While im mentioning the facebook editorial team, i must say – despite the negative criticism ive seen on blogs (mostly affiliate marketing blogs) they seem to be fair and rational. As long as you are not trying to trick someone into something they dont want to do – and your ad is actually an advertisement for the page you are taking the user, you will be fine and your ads will get approved. 

Thats it for now on editorial team & speed – more on that in post dedicated to the subject. 

So if im not talking about the time it takes to approve an ad what am i talking about? 

The time it takes for your ad to reach maximum (or at least decent) exposure. In my (limited) testing it takes approx 36 hours – after your ad is approved – before you see the type of impressions / clicks that will be normal for the ad. While i have observed this with many ads, im going to post 1 example below on a pretty new ad i have been running this week on fb. Take a look at the following screengrab. 

Facebook Ads Timeline

Looking at the report screen above you can see, that on 2/08 i got 49 clicks (note; 2/8 is the first day i got clicks on this ad – not sure why the facebook ad UI only lets you view the stats by “Daily stats for the week of XXX”). So everything was looking good & the next day 2/09 i got a nice amount of clicks on the ad (264) but was wondering if there is where i would be capped (obviously changing the ad, targeting &/or cpc would change the click volume – but i wanted to see what this ad/targeting/cpc combo would generate). 

Much to my suprise, the next day the ad generated almost double the amount of clicks (463) while the cpc, avg cpc & CTR % stayed exactly the same. 

I have a strike through  2/11 bec this report was run in the morning on 2/11 and it is only showing partial stats for the day. but i can tell you, that as of writing this at 3pm on 2/11 the numbers today look identical to yesterday.

So while this is only 1 example of a facebook ad that took ~36 hours, i have seen this time and time again with the numerous facebook ad campaigns i have been creating & managing. I expect that as time goes on, this process will happen faster & advertisers will be able to almost turn the click-faucet (think adwords ;)

Please let me know what you think in the comments.








Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.